Categories
dogs explaining tricks Explainism good explanations questions & answers

Explaining Lessons From the Front Lines of Dog Rescue

My wife and I spend many of our Saturdays helping out a with a dog rescue group’s adoption events. Volunteers bring 25 or so adoptable dogs to a Petco in a busy strip mall, line them up in crates outside, and meet the public.

It’s quite the spectacle, and it attracts a diverse crowd. At one extreme, we talk to potential adopters who have researched dog breeds extensively and browsed our Web site to make a list of specific dogs they want to meet. On the other end of the spectrum, we talk to shoppers strolling by who’ve never even heard of dog rescue.



Dog explainists at work. The “Low Prices!” are on dog food, not dogs.

I’m fascinated (if occasionally frustrated) by the people on the confused end of the scale because they’re such perfect explanation test cases. If you don’t know anything about rescue, the sight of two dozen yapping dogs in crates on the sidewalk must be bizarre. I imagine you don’t even know where to begin to make sense of things. Meanwhile, the only explainers around — the volunteers — know so much about dog rescue that it’s hard for them to empathize with your confusion. There’s a huge understanding gap.

Typically, the confused people dive right in with questions. Occasionally, someone will ask, “What’s going on here?” but more often, the first question is something specific like “How much does that dog cost?” or “How do I get a dog?”

When I first started volunteering, I would just answer the questions as they came. But pretty soon I realized some people were only getting more confused, and more convinced I was nuts. My answers didn’t make sense to the questioner because the questioner wasn’t starting with a blank knowledge slate. They had already filled in a few key gaps with assumptions, based on their own guesses.

In the case of dog rescue, confused people typically make one of two incorrect assumptions:

  1. We are operating a business, and we make a profit by selling these dogs.
  2. We are trying to get rid of these dogs as quickly as we can. (i.e. we are a “free puppies” ad on a larger scale.)

If you believe either one of these things, our policies are going to seem counter-intuitive. Adopting a dog from our group involves filling out a six-page application and going through a rigorous week-long screening process — not exactly the behavior you would expect from a money-making venture or a “take my dogs, please” operation. And our adoption fee is more than you would expect to see in a Craigslist puppy ad. When you start with a misconception, it seems like we’re going about things all wrong.

So, I learned to drain these assumptions before pouring more information in. I learned that just about everything I say will be misconstrued unless I explain my motivation first.

In other words, I learned to answer the ideal initial question, instead of the actual initial question. No matter what the actual question was, my opening spiel now goes something like this:

“We’re an all-volunteer non-profit group, and our mission is to find homes for dogs in need. Many of these dogs come from overcrowded county animal shelters or shut-down breeder operations. Some were abandoned by their original owners. We spay or neuter them, give them all their shots, treat any problems and care for them until they are adopted. Since these dogs have had a rough start in life, we spend a lot of time making sure the adopters and dogs are a perfect match.”

If there’s still head-scratching, I may get into statistics on how many dogs have to be euthanized every year because of overpopulation. Despite Bob Barker’s best efforts, a lot of people don’t know anything about this.

Once someone understands what our motivation is, the details of our process and policies make much more sense, even if the whole thing still seems kooky.

This principle applies to most explaining situations. For example, if you’re pitching a business idea, the details are likely to be confusing unless you thoroughly explain the basic purpose of your business first. Your audience is likely to fill in their own rationale for the business, which may not line up with the actual rationale. The details and baseline assumptions won’t match, and confusion will flourish. Or consider how you explain technology. Unless you lay out a machine’s function, details of how the various pieces operate won’t make much sense.

It’s a handy rule. Before you dig in to the specifics, scrub away all incorrect assumptions and clearly explain your motivation. First, answer the best question an audience could have asked, then answer the questions they did ask.

3 replies on “Explaining Lessons From the Front Lines of Dog Rescue”

Great post! A couple of things stood out for me. One, it’s an interesting case of the “Curse of Knowledge” – explainers knowing too much to imagine what it’s like not to know.

Second, the value of building context and making them care as a priority. We’re really oriented around the idea that an explanation should make someone care. If they care, they’ll be more motivated figure out the details. By putting the details first, people have a harder time seeing the value in learning more.

Great work you’re doing with the rescue too! Cheers!

Thanks, Lee! Great point about the importance of caring. In the case of dog rescue, a big challenge is getting people who already care about dogs to channel that caring in the particular way we do. An animal lover may see a dog and want desperately to get him out of his crate and bring him home immediately. We don’t work that way, and if you don’t understand why, it’s easy to see us as the bad guy keeping you from doing a good thing. Many times, I’ve seen people in this situation reach a magic tipping of understanding. Once they see what we’re up against, they’re suddenly on our side and can make sense of our policy details.

This post reminds me of an advertisement I’ve been hearing lately that drives me crazy, since advertisements are another kind of “this is what it’s all about” strategy. There is an investment company that underwrites my local public radio station, and their slogan is something like “investment involves many risks, including the risk of loss.” What? I think they’re trying to say talk about the risk of a lost opportunity, but it just comes off sounding like “you might earn money, or you might not!” I feel like they’re missing an opportunity (ha!) to gain customers by explaining what they’re all about.

Leave a Reply to Patrick Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *